5 min read

Your Agency's Content Is a Cost. Do You Know What It's Earning?

Your Agency's Content Is a Cost. Do You Know What It's Earning?
What Is Your Agency's Content Costing You? A CPA's View
8:11

By Craig S. Cody, CPA, Certified Tax Coach.

A new Edelman and LinkedIn survey found that 59% of B2B decision-makers said weak or missing thought leadership contributed to a vendor being removed from consideration. That's a marketing finding, and you know marketing far better than I do. I'm a CPA. So I won't tell you how to write a better post.

I'll ask the question I'd ask about any other expense on your P&L: what does your content cost, and what is it bringing back? Those are two numbers that are easy to skip, because the biggest cost of content never shows up as a bill. Here's how to get both in an afternoon, without new software.

What Did the Survey Actually Find?

On November 13, O'Dwyer's reported on "From Found to Chosen," a study from Edelman and LinkedIn of 1,135 business executives across seven countries, surveyed in September.

  • 59% said low-quality thought leadership, or none at all, contributed to a vendor being removed from consideration.
  • 52% said thought leadership helped their purchasing group choose a vendor.
  • 78% researched a company after seeing its content cited by AI.

Now let me be careful about what it doesn't say. It's a survey of B2B executives across every industry, not agency prospects. It doesn't mean 59% of your prospects behave this way, and "contributed to" isn't "caused." What it does say is that a lot of buyers do their homework before they ever talk to you.

What I See From My Side of the Table

My firm isn't an agency, and I'm not a marketer. But we're a professional firm that wins clients who don't switch lightly. In my business, we know changing CPAs is hard. And prospects are always letting us know they searched for our content before speaking with us.

Your clients choosing an agency are making the same kind of decision: disruptive, expensive to get wrong, and hard to undo. So I'm not surprised the survey found buyers checking first.

It's also why we publish what our tax plan costs, right on our blog, next to the return a client should expect from it. Cost is the first question a buyer has, and I'd rather answer it before the call than dodge it on the call.

What goes into your content is your call and your team's. What it costs and what it earns is mine.

What Does Your Agency's Content Actually Cost?

Start with time, because that's where most of the money is. Count every hour that goes into a month of your own content: writing, editing, design, review, posting, and the meetings about all of it.

Then put a price on those hours:

  • Your team's hours. Use a loaded hourly cost: salary, plus employer payroll taxes, plus benefits, divided by the hours each person is actually available to work. Not their billable rate. Their cost.
  • Your own hours. These never show up on the P&L as content, but they aren't free. Price them at what you'd pay to hire someone to do that work. It's the same replacement-cost view a buyer takes when they look at your owner compensation.
  • Hard costs. Tools, freelancers, design, video, and any paid promotion behind the content.

An illustrative example: 20 hours a month at a $100 loaded cost is $2,000 a month, or $24,000 a year, before a single tool. Your numbers will be different. The point is to have a number at all.

Here's why it matters beyond the total. Drew McLellan and the Agency Management Institute put healthy agency people costs at or under 55% of agency gross income (AGI, your revenue after pass-through costs like media). The hours your humans spend on your own content are people cost that never gets billed to a client. They count against that 55% whether you track them or not.

How Do You Know What It's Earning?

You don't need attribution software. You need one question and a place to write the answer down.

  • Ask it on every first call: "What did you read or watch before you reached out?"
  • Log the answer in your CRM on the contact or the deal, the same way every time.
  • When the deal closes, note the first-year AGI from that client.

After two quarters, put the two numbers side by side: what your content cost, and the AGI from new clients who told you content brought them in. That's not forensic accounting. It's a direction check, the same way a monthly P&L tells you which way you're heading before the year-end numbers are final.

Be honest about the limit. This only catches the prospects who mention it. A referral who looked you up and never said so won't show up, and the survey suggests that kind of homework is common. So treat the number as a floor, not the whole story.

What If the Number Comes Back Ugly?

Don't cut on one bad quarter. And don't ask me how to fix the content. That's your expertise, not mine.

What I'll push you on is deciding on purpose. Either content is an investment you're measuring against new AGI, or it's brand awareness you've chosen to fund at a set amount. Both are fine. What isn't fine is a five-figure line nobody can explain. And cutting to zero isn't free either: "none at all" is part of that 59%.

Who Is This Not For?

If you're a solo shop and content is your own nights and weekends, the hard-cost math barely matters. The number that matters is your time, and the same replacement-cost question applies.

And if you already track content cost and lead source by deal, you're ahead of this article. Use it to check that owner hours are in the cost.

What Can You Do Monday Morning?

Add the "what did you read before you reached out?" question to your intake call, and add a field for the answer on your deals. Then pull last month's calendar, total the hours you and your team spent on your own content, and multiply by loaded cost.

That's an afternoon of work. In two quarters, you'll know whether your content is an expense or an investment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does thought leadership affect B2B buying decisions?

In the 2026 Edelman and LinkedIn study, 52% of B2B decision-makers said thought leadership helped their purchasing group choose a vendor, and 59% said weak or missing thought leadership contributed to removing a vendor from consideration. The survey covered business executives across industries, not agency buyers specifically.

How do I calculate what my agency's content costs?

Total the hours everyone spends on your own content each month, multiply by each person's loaded hourly cost (salary, employer payroll taxes and benefits, divided by available hours), price the owner's hours at replacement cost, then add tools, freelancers and paid promotion.

How do I know if my agency's content is bringing in clients?

Ask every prospect on the first call what they read or watched before reaching out, log the answer in your CRM, and record the first-year agency gross income when the deal closes. After two quarters, compare that AGI to what the content cost. Treat it as a floor, because not every prospect mentions it.

Does time spent on our own marketing count as people cost?

Yes. Salaries are people cost whether the hours go to client work or your own content. In AMI's 55/25/20 model, people costs should run at or under 55% of agency gross income, and nonbillable hours on your own marketing count toward that.

Let's Talk

Marketing is your expertise. Knowing what it costs and what it earns is mine, and that's a conversation I'm always happy to have. If you want to see how I think about agency finances in one place, I wrote a book for agency owners. You can request a free copy at the link below.

Request your free copy

Craig S. Cody is a CPA, Certified Tax Coach, and retired NYPD Lieutenant. His firm works with more than 75 marketing and advertising agency owners every month, helping them keep more of what they make through proactive tax planning.

This article is general education, not advice for your specific situation. Confirm your own facts with your advisor before acting.

Your Agency's Content Is a Cost. Do You Know What It's Earning?

Your Agency's Content Is a Cost. Do You Know What It's Earning?

Content is a line on your P&L. Here's how to price the hours behind it, including yours, and check what it brings back in new agency gross income.

Read More
Acquisitions Are Rising Into 2027. Would Your Agency Pass a Buyer's First Look?

Acquisitions Are Rising Into 2027. Would Your Agency Pass a Buyer's First Look?

Half of large-company finance leaders expect an acquisition in 2027. Here are the five checks a buyer runs on your agency first, from EBITDA to state...

Read More
Hawke Bought a Specialist PR Firm. What Part of Your Agency Would a Buyer Pay For?

Hawke Bought a Specialist PR Firm. What Part of Your Agency Would a Buyer Pay For?

Hawke Media is buying Ketner Group, a B2B tech PR specialist. What buyers pay for in a niche agency, and three tests to prove yours in the books.

Read More