5 min read

Bringing In a Partner or Outside Capital? First Ask What the Money Would Actually Fix.

Bringing In a Partner or Outside Capital? First Ask What the Money Would Actually Fix.
Outside Capital for Your Agency: 5 Questions Before a Buy-In
8:15

By Craig S. Cody, CPA, Certified Tax Coach.

Outside money, whether it's a new partner buying in or an investor taking a stake, can speed up an agency that already makes money the right way. It can't fix one that doesn't. Capital makes the model it lands in bigger, so a thin margin, fragile revenue or an owner who is the whole business gets bigger too. Before you take a dollar, answer five questions: does every client make money, will the revenue last, does the agency run without you, where does your cash go, and what exactly will this money buy?

I almost always recommend fixing everything before bringing in new money. Otherwise that new money can be very expensive.

Why Is This Coming Up Now?

Because agencies are doing it. At the end of October, the creative agency Special, founded in New Zealand and now eight offices, took investment from the private equity firm Waterman Capital. The size of the stake wasn't disclosed. What was disclosed is what the money is for: new geographic markets, design, PR and strategy services, stronger technology, and talent. Its partners keep running their businesses.

Notice that last part. Special said what the money would buy. That's the question most owners skip.

Where Does the Money Actually Go?

This is the first thing to get straight, because owners often mix up two very different deals.

When a partner buys shares from you, the money goes to you. You've sold part of your agency. That can be a fine thing to do, but nothing inside the agency changes. Its margin, its clients and its cash are exactly where they were the day before.

When a partner or investor buys new shares from the agency, the money goes into the business. That's the only version where capital can fund something. Many deals are a mix, so ask for the split in writing: how much goes to you, and how much stays in the agency.

Question 1: Does Every Client Make Money?

Capital funds more of what you already do. If some clients lose money once you count the real hours, more capital buys more of those clients.

Start with gross margin by client: what each client paid, less the cost of the humans and outside spend it took to serve them. If a handful of clients carry the rest, fix that before you add fuel. I walk through how your delivery lead can track it in your delivery leader needs a margin number.

Question 2: Will the Revenue Last?

An investor or a new partner is paying today for income they expect to collect for years. The more of your revenue that's contracted and recurring, the more that bet is worth, and the better the terms you'll get.

If most of last year came from one-time projects, outside money is being asked to bet on your next sale. I explain how to sort it in not all agency revenue is worth the same.

Question 3: Does the Agency Run Without You?

If the clients, the pricing and the big decisions all run through you, a partner isn't buying an agency. They're buying you, and you're the one asset they can't own.

That changes the deal. Expect longer commitments from you, more of the price tied to future results, and less freedom after closing. Special's announcement made a point of who leads each office after the money arrives. Yours should be able to as well. I cover where the owner's hours should go in your most expensive delivery hour is the owner's.

Question 4: Where Does Your Cash Go?

Many owners go looking for capital because cash feels tight. Before you raise money for that, find out why it's tight.

If the cash is stuck in slow receivables, unbilled work or distributions bigger than the business can support, new money fills the hole for a while and then the hole comes back. That's a collections and billing problem, not a capital problem. Fixing it is cheaper than selling equity. I go through it in your agency made a profit, did it make the cash?

Question 5: What Exactly Will the Money Buy?

This is the one that decides the rest. Write it in one sentence, with a number and a date:

  • Weak: "Growth." "Flexibility." "Taking it to the next level."
  • Strong: "Two senior hires to open a PR practice, paid back from that practice's margin within 24 months."

If you can't write the strong version, you're not ready to sell equity, because you can't tell a partner what they're paying for, and you can't tell later whether it worked.

What About the Tax and Structure Side?

Plenty of agencies are S corporations, and that changes who can invest.

An S corporation can only have certain shareholders: individuals, plus some estates, trusts and tax exempt organizations. A private equity fund or another company generally can't own the shares directly. An S corporation can also have only one class of stock, so the preferred returns investors often want don't fit. Both rules are in section 1361 of the tax code.

A new individual partner buying in is usually fine. Institutional money usually means restructuring before the deal, and that takes planning time you want to start early, not the week the term sheet arrives. And if the partner is buying your shares, that sale is a taxable event for you, so model what you keep after tax before you agree on a price.

Who Is This Not For?

If you're selling your whole agency, this isn't your article. A full sale is its own set of decisions.

If you're bringing in a key employee as a small partner, mostly to keep them, the five questions still matter, but the money is rarely the point. The agreement is. Make sure the buy-sell terms are settled before anyone signs.

What Can You Do This Week?

  1. Ask where the money goes: to you, to the agency, or how much of each.
  2. Pull gross margin by client for the last twelve months.
  3. Sort last year's revenue into contracted, repeat and one-time.
  4. List the decisions only you make and the clients who only call you.
  5. Write the one-sentence use of proceeds, with a number and a date. If you can't, stop there.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can outside capital fix a low-margin agency?

No. Outside money funds more of what the agency already does. If the margin model is broken, capital makes the losses bigger, not smaller. Fix gross margin by client before taking on a partner or investor.

When a partner buys into my agency, where does the money go?

It depends on the deal. If the partner buys your existing shares, the money goes to you and nothing inside the agency changes. If they buy new shares from the agency, the money goes into the business. Many deals mix the two, so get the split in writing.

What should I check before bringing in an investor?

Five things: gross margin by client, how much revenue is contracted and recurring, whether the agency runs without you, where your cash is going, and exactly what the money will buy, written in one sentence with a number and a date.

Can a private equity firm invest in an S corporation?

Generally not directly. An S corporation's shareholders are limited to individuals and certain estates, trusts and tax exempt organizations, and it can have only one class of stock. Institutional investors usually require restructuring first.

Is selling shares to a partner taxable?

Yes, if you sell your own shares, it's a sale and you'll owe tax on any gain. If the agency issues new shares to the partner, the money goes to the business instead. Model what you keep after tax before agreeing on a price.

Let's Talk

If you're thinking about a partner or outside money, the time to plan the structure and the tax is before the conversation starts. Book a Free Tax Analysis. It starts with a short 15-minute call, so nothing sensitive changes hands before we've talked. Email me at craig@ccodycpa.com to schedule it, or request one with the form on this page.

Craig S. Cody is a CPA, Certified Tax Coach, and retired NYPD Lieutenant. His firm works with more than 70 marketing and advertising agency owners every month, helping them keep more of what they make through proactive tax planning.

This article is general education, not advice for your specific situation. Confirm your own facts with your advisor before acting.

Bringing In a Partner or Outside Capital? First Ask What the Money Would Actually Fix.

Bringing In a Partner or Outside Capital? First Ask What the Money Would Actually Fix.

Outside capital speeds up an agency that works and magnifies one that doesn't. Where buy-in money really goes, five questions to ask, and the S corp...

Read More
Your Agency Can Grow and Still Get Less Valuable. Here's How to Tell Which Growth You Had.

Your Agency Can Grow and Still Get Less Valuable. Here's How to Tell Which Growth You Had.

Revenue grew but the agency got less valuable? How pass-through, your biggest client, thin margins, slow cash and owner time turn growth into risk.

Read More
Your Whale Client Won't Stay Forever. Move Its Profit Where It Can't Leave With Them.

Your Whale Client Won't Stay Forever. Move Its Profit Where It Can't Leave With Them.

A whale client's profit is safest outside the agency. Where to put it every year, what each bucket can and can't do, and the 2025 IRS rules on...

Read More